Katie Holmes had Dawson’s Creek fans feeling like it was 2003 again after she reunited with her former on-screen (and off-screen) love interest Joshua Jackson in New York City on Monday—and now, she’s got the Joey Potter-approved wardrobe to match.

Dawson’s Creek may have ended over 20 years ago, but that doesn’t mean fans don’t still have a soft spot for the ensemble. The tight-knit Dawson’s Creek cast has remained close over the years, even reuniting for the 20th anniversary of the show,

Dawson’s Creek stars Katie Holmes and Joshua Jackson joyfully reunited on the Happy Hour film set, reminiscing Capeside High School days.