If you look up "oyster ice cream", you'll often come across articles claiming it was a favorite of George Washington as well as James and Dolly Madison; that it was served at the White House ...

His successor’s wife, Dolley Madison, had more exotic tastes, with a predilection for oyster ice cream. By 1932, Good Humor ...

Read the full review here. Yes, I made a face too when the dish was placed in front of me and I was told that it was an oyster ice-cream. I mean, what on earth is an oyster ice-cream? And who in ...